Stories posted are written by National news Journalists, not by this blog.
Our Blog Tips

WA- Man in protective custody unit hangs himself with bedsheet

2-24-2009 Washington:

A 52-year-old Centralia man died after hanging himself with a bedsheet Saturday night in the Lewis County Jail.

He hanged himself sometime between 5:40 and 6:18 p.m. Saturday night, said Lewis County Chief Deputy Stacy Brown.

The man was taken to Providence Centralia Hospital, where he was pronounced dead.

The man had been in the jail’s protective custody unit, Brown said.

“Usually that means they’re there for a reason, that there’s been something that’s caused them to be put in a safe location,” Brown said.

Prisoners in the unit are subjected to routine checks, she said.

The man, whose name has not been released, had been returned to the Lewis County Jail during a legal appeal. He was a registered sex offender from a 2001 child molestation case, Brown said.

This is the second suicide in the Lewis County Jail in a year.

On April 15, 2008, Michael Bridgman, 39, was found hanging from a bedsheet during a routine check of his single-person cell.

That 2008 case was believed to be the first suicide in the Lewis County Jail in 20 years, with the last suicide reported on April 14, 1988. ..Source.. by The (Centralia) Chronicle

ID- Boise prison inmate found dead in his cell; officials say he likely took his own life

2-16-2009 Idaho:

A 40-year-old prison inmate at the Idaho State Correctional Institution south of Boise was found dead in his cell Saturday morning, according to a spokesman for the Idaho Department of Correction.

Walter Clarence Prichard was found unresponsive in his cell at 6:04 a.m. The Ada County Sheriff's Office is investigating Prichard's death as an apparent suicide.

Correction spokesman Jeff Ray said Prichard had attached something to his bed and his neck, leaned forward and apparently hung himself. He was the only person in his cell.

Prichard was serving 15 years to life in prison for lewd and lascivious conduct with a minor under 16 years old. He was sentenced in Ada County on July 1, 2004. He was eligible to be considered for parole in 2019.

Idaho State Correctional Institution is a medium security prison for men south of Boise. It opened in 1974 and has a capacity of 1,490 inmates. ..Source.. by Katy Moeller - Idaho Statesman

OK- Officials identify dead inmate

2-16-2009 Oklahoma:

Lawton police have identifed an inmate found dead in his GEO prison cell, 8607 SE Flower Mound, on Friday night.

Lawton police and emergency personnel were dispatched to the prison around 10 p.m. on the report of a possible suicide. Lawton Police Department Capt. Jackie LaRoche said when officers arrived, they found 31-year-old Billy Joe Roberts dead after hanging himself with rope from a bunk.

According to the Oklahoma Department of Corrections, Roberts was serving a 35-year sentence for stealing a car, attempting to evade a police officer and sexual battery in 2008 in Ottawa County. He was convicted in November 2008 and was transferred to Lawton in January. ..Source.. by JOSH ROUSE

MD- Officials: Inmate accused of rape commits suicide

2-16-2009 Maryland:

Police say there were no warning signs

Investigators believe a county jail inmate hanged himself inside a shower stall on Friday morning, two days after police served him court documents charging him with incest and related counts, according to the Cecil County Sheriff’s Office.

Police identified the apparent suicide victim as Frank Franklin Fowler, 28, of the 100 block of Castlestone Road in Elkton. ..Source.. by Carl Hamilton

CA- Bethel Child Porn Suspect Found Dead

2-12-2009 California:

Bethel police say a man arrested on child porn charges killed himself in a San Diego jail today. John Kopkowski was found in his cell around 12:30 this afternoon. Officials say it appears his death is a suicide.

Kopkowski was arrested last Friday in San Diego after going to a hospital there for medical treatment. Investigators say Kopkoski's father lives in that area.

A Clermont County grand jury indicted Kopkowski on fifty charges. The investigation into Kopkowski started in December when he brought a computer in for repairs. The repair shop called police after discovering hundreds of pictures of young boys and girls - they were either nude or involved in sex acts.

Police searched Kopkowski's Batavia home - where they found several pieces of children's clothing.

Kopkowski was not fighting extradition and was expected back in Clermont County later this week. ..Source.. by Local12.com

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Kopkowski dies in prison

After almost two months of investigation local police have been given a swift conclusion to the case involving a Batavia man who was indicted on 50 counts relating to child pornography Feb. 4.

John Kopkowski, 42, was pronounced dead at the San Diego Central Jail at about 9:34 a.m. San Diego, Cali. time Thursday, Feb. 12. According to Bethel Police Officer Shane Bininger preliminary reports indicate that Kopkowski jumped from the second level of a building at the jail while in protective custody, falling to his death. His death is being investigated by the San Diego Sheriff’s Office. No further information is available at this time.

The Bethel Police Department began investigating Kopkowski on Dec. 12 after a Bethel computer repair technician came forward with the allegation that he had found disturbing images on Kopkowski’s computer. The Bethel PD along with the Batavia Police Department executed a warrant on Kopkowski’s home in Batavia on Dec. 14. The officers confiscated two computers which contained hundreds of images containing children in various states of nudity and engaging in sexual acts.

Kopkowski was located by the Department of Veteran Affairs Police Department when he visited a VA Hospital in San Diego, Cali. He was arrested on Feb. 6 and was awaiting extradition to Ohio when he died.

Bininger said that while the case on Kopkowski will be closed the Bethel Police will continue to work with the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Identification and Investigations to determine if there are victims who were involved with Kopkowski.

“Unfortunately we’re not going to be able to proceed with prosecution,” Bininger said. “If we are able to determine there were any victims we will work with the agencies that currently have open investigations. Unfortunately at this point we don’t know who the victims are. We are going to continue to do everything within our power, within the power of the state of Ohio to determine who these victims are.”

Bethel worked with with numerous local agencies to analyze evidence recovered from Kopkowski’s home in Batavia including the Batavia Police Department, Miami Township Police Department, BCI, Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office-Regional Electronics Computer Investigation Unit, Department of Veterans Affairs Police Department and the Federal Bureau of Investigation. Images recovered from the computers were also sent to United States Postal Inspection Service and the Center for Missing and Exploited Children to investigate whether the children in the images have been involved in past investigations.

“We’re not going to leave any stone unturned,” Bininger said. ..Source.. by Staff

CO- Sex assault suspect commits suicide

2-12-2009 Colorado:

A Fountain man who shot himself in a Sears store parking lot in Colorado Springs Monday afternoon was an elementary school teacher under investigation for sexually assaulting an underaged family member, Fountain police said today.

"The investigation had nothing to do with his work at the school," said Lt. Mike Haley of the Fountain Police Department.

Monday morning, however, Louis Aragon, 38, a teacher at Otero Elementary School in Colorado Springs, was placed on administrative leave by the school district because of the investigation, Haley said.

He called his wife at about 2 p.m. to tell her where she could find the car and then shot himself, according to police

The investigation will continue to determine whether the charges against Aragon were founded "and, if so, there could be more victims out there," Haley said. ..Source.. by Denver Post

WA- Molestation suspect reportedly kills himself

5-30-2006 Washington:

An accused child molester from Olympia stole some guns and drove into the Stampede Pass area off Interstate 90, then killed himself, Kittitas County sheriff's deputies said. The body of Michael A. Durbiano IV, 38, was recovered about noon Friday after authorities spotted his burned-out vehicle from the air, Undersheriff Clayton Myers said in a news release. According to Myers, authorities were notified by Durbiano's family Thursday night that Durbiano had stolen several guns and drove into the mountains near Stampede Pass, about 10 miles south of Snoqualmie Pass.

Durbiano was facing child molestation charges in Thurston County and, according to Myers, was reportedly ready to shoot any members of law enforcement who came into the area. With the aid of a Washington State Patrol aircraft, a Kittitas County sheriff's deputy spotted a burned-out vehicle about five miles south of the freeway at 10 a.m. Friday. Myers said the Kittitas County Special Response Team found Durbiano's body in the treeline about 50 yards from his vehicle. A loaded hunting rifle, shotgun and .45-caliber handgun were recovered.

A preliminary investigation indicated Durbiano torched his vehicle and then shot himself in the head, Myers said. The body was taken to Ellensburg for an autopsy. According to court records, Durbiano was charged with two counts of second-degree child molestation in January. That same day, an anti-harassment protection order was signed by a Thurston County judge. A trial date of July 19 was pending. A hearing in the case was held Thursday. Myers said Durbiano reportedly vowed he was not .going back to jail. ..Source.. by CHRIS BRISTOL, YAKIMA HERALD-REPUBLIC

GA- Domestic fight ends in death

6-5-2006 Georgia:

A registered sex offender living in Register killed himself Wednesday afternoon after setting his home on fire, investigators said. Robert Antonio Thompson, 30, Triple T Road, ran from responding law enforcement officers after his wife called for help, said Bulloch County Sheriff’s Chief Deputy Gene McDaniel. The woman, whom investigators did not name, picked Thompson up Wednesday afternoon from Denmark Street in Statesboro, and stopped at a convenience store in Register on the way home, he said.

At The Store in Register (the name of the convenience store), the couple argued. They had been separated for about a month, he said. However, it was unclear what caused the disagreement, he said. After returning home a few miles away from the store, Thompson’s wife called law enforcement, he said. When Bulloch County Sheriff’s Capt. Lee Harris arrived at the Triple T Road home around 4:30 p.m., Thompson fled into the woods, he said. “That’s when Capt. Harris realized the mobile home was on fire,” McDaniel said.

Harris called for firefighters and for backup to locate Thompson. Local businessman Ellis Wood, who often assists law enforcement, arrived by helicopter to help officers in the search for Thompson while firefighters extinguished the blaze, McDaniel said. The mobile home, which was empty except for a small dog, was gutted, he said. The dog escaped the blaze uninjured. A short time later, Wood spotted Thompson’s body behind the home, he said. “He had apparently placed a pistol to his head and shot himself.”

Thompson was convicted of rape in August, 1996, according to information from the Bulloch County Sheriff’s Department web site (www.bullochsheriff.com). He was also convicted in 1997 of criminal interference with government property, obstruction and underage possession of alcohol, serving a five-year sentence and released in August, 2001, according to the Georgia Department of Corrections web site. ..Source.. by HOLLI DEAL BRAGG

NV- Authorities: Man who killed himself in stand-off was convicted sex offender

2-10-2009 Nevada:

RENO, Nev. (AP) - Authorities say a man who shot himself during a police stand-off on a Reno freeway was wanted for being a convicted sex offender and not registering his address.

Records show 32-year-old Ricardo Rivas-Ramirez also previously threatened to shoot himself during disputes and had restraining orders against him filed by previous girlfriends.

Washoe County's medical examiner says Rivas-Ramirez died of a self-inflicted gunshot wound to the chest.

Authorities say Rivas-Ramirez was speeding in a Jaguar when he was pulled over around midnight Friday on a busy freeway interchange.

He was found dead in the car after an eight-hour stand-off. ..Source.. by KTVN

OH- Kenneth Conway of Stow kills himself after two girls accuse him of sexual assault, police say

2-4-2009 Ohio:

STOW -- A 45-year-old man accused of molesting two girls and holding a knife to their throats killed himself today, police said.

Kenneth S. Conway of Cox Drive was found dead of a self-inflicted gunshot wound in his home after a 90-minute stand-off with police and the SWAT unit, Lt. Rick Myers said

Myers said police were called about a man who was sitting in a chair holding a gun and possibly contemplating suicide. While police were on the way there, they learned that two sisters, ages 12 and 13, had told their mother that Conway had held a knife to their throats and sexually assaulted them.

The girls sustained minor injuries from the assaults. Stow paramedics treated the victims for the injuries and they were sent to Akron Children's Hospital for examination.

When police arrived at Conway's house there was no response from inside. After 90 minutes of silence, SWAT officers entered the house. They found Conway sitting in a chair with a gunshot wound to the head and the firearm was laying on the floor nearby.

He was pronounced dead by Dr. Jo McMullen of Metro SWAT. The Summit County Medical Examiner's Office took the body. ..Source.. by Michael Sangiacomo/Plain Dealer Reporter

IL- Dist. 23 Teacher Facing Charges Found Dead

2-4-2009 Illinois:

A teacher from MacArthur Middle School in Prospect Heights, arrested and charged last Friday (Jan. 30) with allegedly sexually molesting a student, was found dead in his garage in Buffalo Grove early this morning (Monday), according to Buffalo Grove police.

According to police, Ronald Vos, 53, of 502 Longwood Dr., died of an apparent suicide. Police found Vos at approximately 5:45 a.m.

Police said Vos' wife called police after she initially discovered him. Authorities are unsure how long Vos was dead at the time of his finding, but said his wife reported last seeing him around 4 p.m. Sunday.

According to Prospect Heights Police Chief Bruce Morris, Vos was arrested last Friday at his home without incident.

In September 2008, the Prospect Heights Police Dept. was contacted by Dept. of Children and Family Services (DCFS) regarding an allegation of sexual abuse that occurred at MacArthur in September 2005.

Through the investigation that was conducted by Prospect Heights police, with help from the Sex Crimes Unit of the Cook County States Attorney's Office, police said a juvenile victim reported that on one occasion, Vos allegedly sexually assaulted the boy while at school and on three more occasions outside of school between September 2005 and February or March 2007. During that time, the boy was 13-15 years old.

Further investigation produced computer records indicating that Vos and the victim agreed to trade sex for beer and cigarettes, according to Prospect Heights police.

"The investigation began in September 2008 when it was brought to our attention by school staff and the DCFS," said Morris.

But why did it take five months from the initial complaint to the arrest of Vos?

According to Morris, interviewing the child and processing the information takes a long time, because it also includes grand jury subpoenas and access to phones and computers.

Morris said detectives interviewed the child a couple times and Vos was also interviewed twice.

"We needed enough probable cause to make the arrest," said Morris. "We couldn't have made the arrest until we (police) and the State's Attorney were satisfied with all the gathered information."

On Jan. 31, Vos was taken to bond court where a $100,000 bond was set. His next hearing date was set for Feb. 27, at the Rolling Meadows courthouse.

In a Saturday, Jan. 31 letter written to parents, Prospect Heights School Dist. 23 Supt. Dr. Greg Guarrine states, "I regret to inform you that grave allegations have been made against a member of our staff, Mr. Ronald Vos, Computer Education Teacher at MacArthur Middle School. On Sept. 4, 2008, the day misconduct allegations about Mr. Ron Vos surfaced from the Illinois Dept. of Children and Family Services, the administration took immediate action to suspend him and prohibited him from being on the school campus while an investigation was conducted by DCFS and the Prospect Heights Police Dept. This weekend, after an extensive and thorough investigation, Mr. Vos was charged with criminal sexual assault on a former MacArthur student. The safety and welfare of our students is our primary concern. We encourage former and current students to come forward with information regarding allegations of misconduct involving Mr. Vos."

Morris said as of right now there is only one victim police are aware of.

"We are not looking into if there were anymore victims, but if anyone wants to come forward, they can contact the school or the police department."

"DCFS is investigating allegations of abuse in this case based on a report we received Sept. 4, 2008," said Kendall Marlowe, DCFS spokesman. "The investigation is ongoing."

An attempt by the Journal to contact Guarrine and Vos' family for comment was unsuccessful. ..Source.. by RICHARD MAYER Assistant Managing Editor

NY- Sex offender awaiting sentencing found dead in jail cell

2-3-2009 New York:

MADISON COUNTY, N.Y. (WKTV) - An investigation is continuing into the apparent suicide death of an inmate housed in the Madison County Public Safety Building Jail shortly after 2 a.m. Tuesday morning.

According to the Madison County Sheriff, Michael York, 44, was found unresponsive by Corrections Officers as the officers were performing inmate cell checks.

York was treated at the scene by Corrections Officers, members of the Oneida Fire Department and Vineall Ambulance Service.

York was sent to the Oneida Healthcare Facility where he was pronounced dead shortly after his arrival.

He was sent to the Onondaga County Medical Examiners Office where an autopsy will be conducted.

The Madison County Sheriff's Office has notified the New York State Commission of Corrections. In addition to the ongoing Sheriff's Office investigation, the New York State Commission will conduct a routine independent inmate death investigation.

York was incarcerated awaiting County Court sentencing on a charge of criminal sexual act.

The charges stem from 2008, when York had been walking in the Village of Hamilton and asked a village police officer for a ride to Oneida.

Unknown to York, area police were already investigating him after a couple who had been walking their dog along a canal trail in early July reported seeing York and a younger male under the age of 15 engaged in what deputies called "a suspicious incident."

York gave a statement to investigators in Oneida and was then charged with two counts of criminal sexual act. ..Source.. by DAVE DELLECESE

---------------------------------------------------------------------

State faults Madison County Jail after inmate suicide

11-28-2009:

Investigation report said Michael York told investigators he was suicidal even before his arrest and guilty plea

Two days before he was to be sentenced to 15-years-to-life on sexual abuse charges for molesting a teenage boy, Michael York told his wife that he didn’t want to go back to prison. According to the state Commission of Corrections, she later told investigators York said ‘don’t wait around for me; get on with your life.’

According to the report, York’s wife, whom the Commission would not identify by name, left the visitor area at the Madison County Jail and immediately asked a correction officer to keep an eye on York, fearing he was contemplating suicide. It was not the first time authorities were informed of his mental condition, investigators said, yet he was never placed on suicide watch.

York, 44, of Eaton, was found in his cell in the early morning hours of Nov. 3, a torn bed sheet tied around his neck and through a ceiling air vent.

According to an investigation report from the state Commission of Corrections obtained by the Madison County Courier under the Freedom of Information Law, correction officers thought nothing was unusual when they made their rounds and saw York apparently standing near the urinal with his back to them, refusing to acknowledge them during cell checks.

When they circled back a few minutes later, one of them observed that York “appeared taller.” They opened the cell door to find him dead.

The report indicated York left suicide notes for his wife and the judge, but did not detail their content. There was no entry of the suicide in the jail log book, only a note that said “unusual activities noted in E-21.”

According to the report, the corrections officer ignored the woman’s request to keep an eye on York and did not pass that information along to a superior officer. State correction investigators also said a psychiatrist and a social worker from the county Mental Health Department didn’t provide adequate care for York and failed to provide an appropriate treatment plan for him.

York was arrested in July 2008, several days after a pair of hikers witnessed him and a teenage boy engaging in sexual activities in the woods. York, after finding out that he was wanted for questioning, called a Madison County Sheriff’s Office investigator before his arrest and left three messages noting that he was contemplating suicide, according to the report.

On the day of his arrest, he told authorities that he overdosed on medication in a suicide attempt a few hours earlier, but they did not bring him to a hospital, according to the report.

After his arrest, York told a psychiatrist from MHD that his wife had cancer and that he previously attempted suicide. The doctor noted signs of depression and a history of mental health and sex offender treatment, but correction officers noted in jail log records that the inmate “has no thoughts of suicide at this time,” according to the report.

York pleaded guilty to a felony criminal sexual act charge on Nov. 25, 2008. In the jail time that followed he appeared polite and pleasant with jail staff, and he visited with his wife regularly, according to the report. A few days before the suicide, he was observed working on a puzzle and conversing normally with jail staff.

York was already a Level 3 sex offender, the highest classification in the state, due to a previous conviction for abusing a 7-year-old. He also served prison time following a 1997 burglary conviction. His criminal record would have been considered when correction officials considered whether York should ever be released from prison. During York’s guilty plea, defense attorneys said it was unlikely that York would ever be released.

As a result of the investigation’s finding, Sheriff Ronald Cary was ordered to have correctional faculty and medical personnel that works at the jail retrained, though the report did not specify in which areas the training would occur.

Cary has since resigned the office of sheriff.

The Commission of Corrections has also asked the sheriff’s office to review the performance of the officer who spoke to York’s wife after she observed the suicidal behavior. The state Commission of Mental Health has been asked to review the performance of the psychiatrist and social worker who were involved in York’s case.

The report did not include a response from the Madison County Sheriff’s Office. ..Source.. by Aaron Gifford

KS- Johnson County inmate commits suicide

2-2-2009 Kansas:

A 37-year-old Prairie Village man committed suicide Saturday in the Olathe Detention Center, police said.

Jonathan Mark Spooner was found by a deputy with a piece of cloth wrapped around his neck about 10 p.m. Saturday during a routine cell check. Efforts to save him were attempted immediately by deputies and nursing staff on duty, according to the Johnson County Sheriff’s Office. He was pronounced dead at the jail.

Overland Park police arrested Spooner on July 29, 2007. He was being held on 12 counts, including aggravated kidnapping, sexual exploitation of a child and aggravated battery. The crimes, according to police, occurred after one of Spooner’s relatives left a 14-year-old girl and a friend at Spooner’s house.

The girls were tied up and photographed in connection with sexually explicit conduct and were given alcohol and drugs, authorities said. ..Source.. by Michael Mansur

MI- Accused teacher dies from hanging!

6-9-2004 Michigan:

A former Homer teacher was found dead Monday, hours before he was scheduled to be sentenced to prison for having sex with a student. Brian K. Corbitt, 28, was found hanged to death in an apparent suicide Monday in his home near Adrian.

Although the age of consent to have sex in Michigan is 16, Corbitt was charged under a law enacted in June 2003 making it illegal for a teacher to have sex with a student in the same school. Corbitt was the first person charged in Calhoun County with that violation and Hotchkiss said his client may be the first person charged similarly in Michigan. In a written statement to the court, Corbitt said he and the girl, now 17, began their relationship at school and first started having sex in March.

"It was absolutely consensual," Hotchkiss said. "That has never been disputed." In his written statement, Corbitt said, "I thought we were genuinely in love. I didn't know it was a crime." Corbitt, a graduate of Michigan State University, who received his master's degree this year, had been a teacher at Homer for three years and was the FFA adviser. ..Source.. by Trace Christenson

MI- BRIAN DICKERSON: A plea deal thwarted, a life is ended

3-24-2004 Michigan:

Ernest Hemingway wrote that every true story ends in death.

This is a true story.

It begins two years ago with a troubled 14-year-old girl who documented her sexual exploits in a diary. She called herself a predator. But Oakland County Prosecutor David Gorcyca was more interested in her slightly older sex partners. He charged four of them with criminal sexual conduct, a felony.

In May 2002, when what became known as the Bloomfield Sex Diary case broke, I argued that Gorcyca had overreacted by bringing criminal charges for what amounted to consensual sex between promiscuous teenagers. I noted that, if convicted, the defendants would be listed on Michigan's sex-offender registry until they reached middle age.

After a public uproar, Gorcyca relented. Under a plea agreement blessed by two sentencing judges, all four defendants were permitted to plead guilty to a lesser charge of seduction. The prosecutor and defense attorneys agreed that none of the defendants would be imprisoned or listed on the sex-offender registry.

The 14-year-old girl and her parents were relieved by the deal. "We didn't have an ax to grind," the girl's attorney, Mayer Morganroth, recalled this week. "Nobody wanted to see these young kids stigmatized for life."

It should have ended there -- a fiasco averted, a case of overzealous prosecution brought to a sane resolution.

But it didn't.

Last month, more than a year after the charges against them were resolved, all four defendants were notified they'd be registered as sex offenders after all.

One of them, 20-year-old Justin Fawcett of West Bloomfield, was particularly devastated. On Feb. 27, three days after Fawcett's probation officer broke the news that he'd be publicly branded for the next 23 years, Fawcett's father e-mailed me to express his fear that Justin would kill himself.

ME- Caught by the past, a child molester kills himself

1998 Maine:

In the dying hours of 1997, in the bleak and black Maine night, Thomas Varnum drank half a bottle of liquor, propped a shotgun between his legs and blasted the top of his head off.

There were very few mourners.

"It may be a terrible thing to say, but I don't think it's a big loss," says David Farley, a lobsterman who lives down the road in Seal Cove.

Not that he knew Varnum well. Not many people around here did. Varnum had moved into the small apartment over Tim Butler's garage in October, just a couple of months after he came to Mount Desert Island.

Nobody paid much attention until Dec. 29, when sheriff's deputies arrived on Kelley Town Road with fliers bearing Varnum's mug shot and his history: He had been convicted of gross sexual assault.

It didn't say precisely what he had done. It didn't say that he had served his time in prison and had been free for a year and a half.

But in the spirit of Megan's Law -- the nationwide movement to ensure that no community should unknowingly harbor a molester -- local officials publicized Varnum's past.

Very few residents saw the fliers. Most of them weren't home when they were distributed. Farley says he didn't learn about Varnum's crimes until later, and the facts unnerved him; he has a 15-year-old daughter who often walked past the house where Varnum lived.

"I'd a killed him if he'd a touched my daughter," Farley says.

Of course, Farley was speaking theoretically. By that time, Varnum had killed himself.

Local interest came and went. "People die here all the time -- by sickness, at sea, in accidents," says Alison Price, chairman of the Tremont Board of Selectmen.
But no one had ever died by Megan's Law -- by the fear that they would be hounded forever for the crimes of the past.

If, in fact, that is what killed Thomas Varnum.

Mount Desert Island is best known as a summer playground-- favored by the Rockefellers, renowned for the beauty of Acadia National Park and the high style of Bar Harbor.

But there is another side of Mount Desert Island, more typical of Downeast Maine. Many of the 10,000 year-round residents struggle. They lobster or fish, work construction, take on odd jobs.

Richard Donovan runs Acadia Muffler and Brake. A bear of a man with gray-blond, shoulder-length hair and a full beard, he employed the 31-year-old Varnum as a mechanic on weekends. He was, he says, Varnum's best friend.

"He loved it down here. He loved the island," says Donovan. "He just liked the people down here. They left him alone."

Is it true that you met in prison?

"I won't talk about that. And I'll tell you what I told another reporter: If you print that, I'll sue you."

An hour later, Donovan is talking all about how he was convicted of sexually assaulting a stepdaughter, a charge that he emphatically denies.

Yes, he says, he met Varnum in prison. No, he insists, he did not know Varnum was a sex offender -- Varnum claimed he was convicted of passing bad checks and beating his wife. Donovan says he believed him.

When Varnum got out, in June 1996, he worked for a mechanic in Bangor but spent his weekends at Donovan's shop in Tremont. He was alone. While he was in prison, his wife divorced him and moved to North Carolina with their daughter.

Last August, Varnum took a construction job in Tremont and moved into Donovan's house, next to the shop.

"As far as I'm concerned, he was a good kid," Donovan says. "He never bothered anybody. He was a funny kid -- a real comical kind of guy."

With that, he comes out from behind the counter and tracks down a battered photo album. Here's a picture of Varnum sitting in a rear seat yanked from a car, a V-6 engine in the wheelbarrow in front of him. Here's another of Varnum, feigning unconsciousness on the driveway, his head on a pompon, a cane on the ground next to him.

"All he was trying to do was to get on with his life," Donovan says. "He made a mistake. Anybody can make a mistake. YOU can make a mistake."

But can Varnum's crimes be described as a single blunder?